Brick Pavers vs Concrete Pavers: Which Holds Up Better in Western PA?

Brick pavers and concrete pavers can both hold up to Western PA winters when each is made to its freeze-rated standard and laid on a sound base. For clay brick, that means ASTM C902 Class SX, which the Brick Industry Association (BIA) says is "intended for use where the pavers may be frozen while saturated with water." For concrete pavers, it means ASTM C936, and the guide specification from the Concrete Masonry & Hardscapes Association (CMHA, formerly the Interlocking Concrete Pavement Institute) lists a freeze-thaw test among its C936 requirements.
BIA's Technical Note 14 (May 2017) lists Class SX clay pavers at a minimum average compressive strength of 8,000 psi (7,000 psi for a single paver), a maximum average cold water absorption of 8.0% (11.0% for a single paver) and a maximum saturation coefficient of 0.78 (0.80 for a single paver). CMHA's guide specification lists ASTM C936 concrete pavers at 8,000 psi average with no unit under 7,200 psi, 5% average absorption with no unit over 7%, and an ASTM C1645 freeze-thaw test in water or a 3% saline solution that allows no more than 225 grams of material lost per square meter of surface after 28 cycles, or 500 grams after 49 cycles. This post covers what those numbers mean in a freeze-thaw winter, which deicers each group recommends, and how color, base work and upkeep compare.

What Standards Do Brick Pavers and Concrete Pavers Meet?
A brick paver is a fired clay paving unit made to ASTM C902, the standard for pedestrian and light traffic paving brick. A concrete paver is a concrete paving unit made to ASTM C936.
C902 sorts clay pavers by weather class. BIA says Class SX is for pavers that may freeze while saturated, Class MX is for exterior use where pavers will not be exposed to freezing, and Class NX is not acceptable for exterior use. BIA adds that "for most exterior residential or light duty applications, Class SX pavers are used."
C902 also sorts pavers by traffic: Type I for extensive abrasion, Type II for intermediate pedestrian traffic such as residential driveways, and Type III for low pedestrian traffic such as patios of single-family homes. BIA adds that "for most exterior residential or light duty applications, Type I or II pavers are used." BIA also says clay pavers for heavy vehicular use, such as streets and commercial driveways, fall under a separate standard, ASTM C1272.
On the concrete side, CMHA says C936 limits a paver to a surface area of no more than 101 square inches and a length to thickness ratio of no more than 4. The two absorption caps come from different test methods (24-hour cold water absorption for clay, ASTM C140 for concrete), so the 8% and 5% figures cannot be compared one to one.
As of October 2026, ASTM lists the 2022 edition of C902 and the 2026 edition of C936 as active, newer than the trade documents quoted here, so check which edition a product's data sheet cites.
How Do Clay and Concrete Pavers Handle Freeze-Thaw Winters?
Freezing nights are routine here. NOAA's 1991 to 2020 normals for Pittsburgh International Airport average more than 100 nights with a low at or below 32 degrees F from November through March alone.
For clay, BIA notes a test-based alternative to the Class SX absorption and saturation coefficient limits: a paver can have those limits waived if it passes the ASTM C67 freezing and thawing test, with no breakage and no more than 0.5 percent dry weight loss.
For concrete, CMHA's guide specification calls for the ASTM C1645 test in water or a 3% saline solution "depending on conditions during service life." CMHA's deicing FAQ adds that C936 includes an optional lower freezing temperature test for regions of the United States with severe freezing. The same guide specification waives freeze-thaw testing for applications not exposed to freezing, and an outdoor patio in Westmoreland County does not qualify.
Brick and Concrete Paver Groups Give Opposite Deicer Advice
BIA's Technical Note 14 says calcium magnesium acetate (CMA) and urea "perform well" on clay pavers, with CMA preferred "because it is more effective at lower temperatures." The same note states, "Rock salt is not recommended," and links its concern to efflorescence.
CMHA takes the opposite position for concrete pavers: "Rock salt (sodium chloride or NaCl) is the least damaging to concrete materials and should be used whenever possible." It adds that "the use of magnesium chloride or CMA is not recommended because they can chemically degrade all types of concrete." If a faster deicer is needed, CMHA suggests sparing use of calcium chloride.
So the deicer that suits a brick patio can be the wrong one for a concrete paver walk beside it. If a project mixes clay brick and concrete pavers, or meets poured concrete steps, ask the installer or the paver maker which deicer to use before the first storm.
Snow removal tools matter too. BIA's Technical Note 14A says shovels and machines "can chip the edges of the pavers, particularly if excessive lipping is present," and BIA says sand or grit used for traction "should be swept up after the freezing cycle."
Which Paver Keeps Its Color Longer, Clay or Concrete?
BIA says the color of clay pavers is typically consistent through the body of the paver "and is highly resistant to weathering and fading because of its vitrified composition." Shades can still vary between production runs, so BIA's Technical Note 14A says "at least two cubes of each color of pavers should be drawn from at one time" during installation.
Concrete pavers typically get their color from added pigment, according to CMHA. Its cleaning and sealing guide says sealers intensify paver colors and that liquid stabilizers can "enhance their color, inhibit fading, and protect against staining." CMHA also says sealers "do not increase the structural properties of the paver," and acrylic sealers generally last a few years before they need recoating.
Is the Base Different Under Clay and Concrete Pavers?
Less than you might expect. BIA's Technical Note 14A says the base under clay paver patios and walkways typically is compacted aggregate at least 4 inches thick. CMHA's construction guide calls for a compacted base of at least 4 inches under concrete paver patios and pedestrian areas and at least 6 inches under residential driveways, both over well-drained soils. CMHA adds, "In colder climates, continually wet or weak soils will require that bases be thicker."
Bedding sand is close, too. BIA lists 3/4 to 1 inch after compaction, and CMHA says to screed it to an uncompacted nominal 1 inch, both using ASTM C33 sand.
CMHA says geotextile may be used over clay and moist silty subgrade soils or where freeze and thaw occur, and it says not to install frozen base or place base over a frozen subgrade. BIA's Technical Note 14A also calls for a minimum slope of 1/4 inch per foot, a 2 percent grade.
Both groups stress the edges. BIA says "edge restraints are critical in a pavement with a sand setting bed to enable consistent interlock," and CMHA says edge restraints are "essential to their performance." For more on base prep over time, see how long paver installation lasts in Western PA and the cost factors behind paver installation, including base work.
What Upkeep Does Each Type of Paver Need?
For clay, BIA's Technical Note 14 says the pavers "are highly resistant to absorption of stains and can be kept clean in most environments by regular sweeping," and it advises testing polymeric sands or cleaners on a small area first, since some have left haze or stains. Technical Note 14A calls for resanding joints periodically and warns that "aggressive pressure-washing can cause localized removal of the joint filling material."
For concrete, CMHA calls joint sand stabilization "generally optional," and treats sealing as optional too. When cleaning, CMHA says "a large amount of water is more important to rinsing than high pressure" and that "scrub brushes with steel bristles are not recommended."
Still deciding whether pavers fit the project at all? This post on pavers vs poured concrete for a patio covers that choice.
FAQ
What does Class SX mean on a clay paver?
BIA describes Class SX as the ASTM C902 weather class for clay pavers that may freeze while soaked with water. Given the freezing nights in a Westmoreland County winter, it is the class to ask for on an outdoor patio or walk.
Can brick pavers be used for a driveway?
Yes, within limits. BIA's Technical Note 9A describes C902 Type I pavers for extensive abrasion "such as driveways or public entries," while heavy vehicular uses call for pavers made to ASTM C1272. For a residential driveway, BIA's Technical Note 14A calls for at least 4 inches of compacted aggregate subbase plus at least 4 inches of base.
Do clay pavers need to be sealed?
BIA's Technical Note 14 describes clay pavers as highly resistant to stains and cleanable by sweeping, and BIA refers coating questions to a separate technical note. For concrete pavers, CMHA treats sealing as optional and says sealers can intensify color but do not add structural strength.
Does efflorescence on new pavers go away?
CMHA says efflorescence "does not affect the structural performance or durability of concrete pavers" and may remain for months, with some of it wearing away. On clay pavers, BIA says it will wear away naturally with traffic and weathering in many cases, and that manufactured limestone sand "usually causes efflorescence."
Which is stronger, a brick paver or a concrete paver?
BIA's Technical Note 14 and CMHA's guide specification for C936 both start at an 8,000 psi average. The single-unit floor differs slightly: 7,000 psi for a Class SX clay paver and 7,200 psi for a C936 concrete paver, and BIA lists lower limits for molded Class SX pavers. Individual products can test higher; Glen-Gery's data sheet for its Steel City Paver Series, for example, lists compressive strength over 10,000 psi.
How thick are brick and concrete pavers?
BIA says C902 clay pavers are commonly made 2 1/4 inches and 1 1/2 inches thick, and the thinner ones are usually installed only over a rigid base. CMHA says C936 concrete pavers are at least 2 3/8 inches thick.
Brick and Paver Patios From Dombrowski Projects
Dombrowski Projects lists brick patios, paver patios and brick and block work among its masonry services, and its concrete and hardscaping work covers pavers for walkways, patios and borders. The family-owned contractor is based in Irwin and serves North Huntingdon, Greensburg, Murrysville, Monroeville and other towns within a 30-mile radius of Irwin. Request a free estimate to talk through a brick or paver patio for your yard.
Visit Dombrowski Projects or call 412-742-6226 today. Contact us for more information.




Comments